[News]

AI Chatbot Promised User US$14,000, Court Says It Doesn't Have to Pay

by Li Jiaohao
January 27, 2026
Share Article:

When an AI chatbot insisted it was right – and offered a 100,000 yuan (US$14,374) wager to prove it – a user surnamed Liang thought he had an open-and-shut case.

But in a landmark ruling, the Hangzhou Internet Court has decided that AI "hallucinations" and empty promises do not constitute legal intent, shielding developers from liability for machine-generated falsehoods.

The case, which marks China's first judicial response to tort claims arising from generative AI errors, dates back to June 2025. Liang had used an AI platform to query university details for his sibling's college application, but the chatbot provided the wrong location for a main campus.

When Liang challenged the error, the system doubled down.

"If the generated content is incorrect, I will compensate you 100,000 yuan," the chatbot declared, even advising Liang to "file a lawsuit at the Hangzhou Internet Court." Only after Liang presented official admissions documents did the AI admit its mistake.

Liang sued the platform's developer for 9,999 yuan, arguing he was misled by false information and entitled to the compensation the bot had promised.

The court rejected his claims in a first-instance judgment that sets significant boundaries for AI liability.

"Artificial intelligence lacks the capacity for civil rights and therefore cannot make legally recognized expressions of intent," the court stated, ruling that a machine's output cannot be interpreted as a binding offer from the provider.

The court found the developer had fulfilled its obligations by implementing user agreements and disclaimers about potential inaccuracies. Under these safeguards, the mere generation of incorrect information – a known phenomenon called "hallucination" – did not amount to a rights infringement.

Finding neither fault nor infringement, the court dismissed all of Liang's claims. Neither party appealed the decision.

#Hangzhou
Share Article:

In Case You Missed It...

[Decades Club] From The Netherlands To Shanghai On Two Wheels
FEATURED
[DECADES CLUB]
[Decades Club] From The Netherlands To Shanghai On Two Wheels
@ Yang Jian,Bu GuanqinLineNov 17, 2026
Fans Pack Cinemas at 3am as China's BLG Wins World Title
[News]
Fans Pack Cinemas at 3am as China's BLG Wins World Title
Fans paid to cheer together on the big screen as Bilibili Gaming secured China's first League of Legends world championship in five years.
Hangzhou Man Sentenced for Making GHB to Drug Girlfriend
[News]
Hangzhou Man Sentenced for Making GHB to Drug Girlfriend
A Hangzhou man received four months in detention for making GHB after using AI to seek recipes, saying he wanted to drug his girlfriend and check her phone.
[Current Trends] Chinese Dramas Win Global Hearts With Timeless Stories and Traditional Aesthetics
[General]
[Current Trends] Chinese Dramas Win Global Hearts With Timeless Stories and Traditional Aesthetics
Historical romance drama "Against the Current" has gained immense popularity both in China and internationally, reaching an amazing audience worldwide.
AISHAISH